And so when Arthur took the fall for rescuing John, and it was revealed that he had helped other people like Rains Fall behind his back, it solidified in Dutch's mind that Arthur was probably the rat, because Dutch figures Arthur needed John there as they were either A, working together, or B, he needed more bodies to distract and deflect blame from himself. I couldn't even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight. One thing is that Dutch probably didnt know that Arthur was captured. And Eagle Flies. NEXT: Red Dead Online: 10 Collector Tips Everyone Should Know. Can you go into any further detail? While trapped on the island of Guarma, Dutch tells the authorities his name is Aiden O'Malley. As soon as he has the sniper position, he has Dutch. It wasn't something they planned and agreed on, but it was something both men came to realize. I like that theory too and it supports the theory Dutch went crazy and thats why he was so paranoid. Of course the man was oozing confidence. Belle uses what little free time she has to play Guild Wars 2 with her partner, work toward that 5-star rating in Animal Crossing, and wonder when the new Dragon Age installment is coming out. After all, Arthur was raised by Dutch and Hosea for nearly twenty years. And he had that as soon as he captured Arthur/the sniper position. Crazy. Think about it, who do you really get a sense for in that first mission? You notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, mainly Dutch. BUT the really interesting thing here comes from some of Colm's dialogue during the mission. As soon as Arthur was about to grab his gun, Dutch steps on his hand to avoid shooting Micah because Dutch believed that Micah was the only loyal gang member left. Image credit: Rockstar Studios/Red Dead Redemption 2 (Youtube/MrBossFTW) By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. If Micah had been in on the capture of Arthur, how would he have convinced Colm to let him leave the parlay with Dutch? Finally, press the left stick up to raise the candle to the wound. If you let him go, he'll run away. I mean he left John to die multiple times throughout this story for his own betterment. A lot of Dutch's past is known to the player and the gang, but some parts of his past must be discovered by exploring and talking to other characters. /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. Arthur Morgan is able to attestThe Count will not let anyone but Dutch ride him. In a struggle with Milton, Arthur is losing until Abigail . Dutch did treat Colms execution as nothing more than a loose end despite being rivals for years. Surely they woulda been concerned as hell. It was? Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. At least, thats the way I see it. Arthur doesn't die; Dutch listens to his people not the rat; The rat dies; Depression; Anger; Language: English Stats: Published: 2022-12-17 Updated: 2023-02-28 . The lack of things like that made that whole section fall super flat for me since there's so little reaction to it at all. But then I think about Micah allways being in his ear and telling him what he wants to hear, stroking his ego, being his yes man and all, and I think that he went mental after SPOILER!! GTA 5 features a book titled Red Dead written by a certain J. Wow I wasnt expecting to get replies to this comment almost a year later. Morgan later witnessed his death and, despite a . Soon we'll come to the river where the canoe's are moored. although there are 4 endings so that will be interesting, kinda sad to see dutch deteriorate though. When Arthur, Micah and Dutch meet Colm and Arthur gets captured When he gets home, Dutch was saying "What, what happened". Dutch apologizes to Arthur on his and Micah's behalf after Arthur flees from O'Driscolls and gets back to the camp all on his own.Thanks for watching!Please . Pearson brings news that Colm ODriscoll has requested a parley. He basically dominated Arthurs life for two decades because of this. Guns are gone and not at the camp after the mission how do I get them back with my gang? Should you desire to do so, youll find the grave of a Mrs. van der Linde. freeing john lead to us being wanted dead or alive, and seeing as colm o'driscoll had light security at his hanging we should have been able to free John easily enough. Interestingly, though, when you meet Evelyn Miller later in the game, he has a completely different personality to the outlaw. They were waiting til first light to try and follow your tracks. You have to go to Rhodes with your gang and they will have your weapons waiting there for you. There is a random camp encounter just after the mission with Dutch that I have only got in 1 of the 3 playthroughs I have done. Right now, it looks as silly as Colm leaving a lock pick within swinging distance of Arthur, all just for dramatic effect and a weird contrivance to move the plot forward. November 2, 2018 by Jack McBastard 9 Comments. The reasoning that he wants to capture the whole gang doesn't really hold water. Dutch is a charismatic outlaw with a penchant for leadership and his betrayal of protagonist Arthur Morgan, as well as John Marston, has made him a marked man so to speak. For more information, please see our There would have been nothing to stop him killing Micah. By that point the Dutch was growing tired of Arthur questioning his plans, and Micah was already spreading the seeds that Arthur was betraying Dutch. It could also because Micah was reassuring Dutch that Arthur would be fine since nothing happened from their side. Recognizing the pattern? Dutch doesn't take it very kindly when he finds out that Arthur had been helping Rains Fall behind his back and he saw that as a betrayal. Also, I dont think youre captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so. In 1887, Dutch led the gang's first major bank robbery alongside Hosea and young Arthur. If you return to camp and just sit still for a while, Dutch will come up to you and explain what he thought happened. Gabrielle "Belle" Huston is a writer and long-time gamer based in Ottawa, Canada. Apparently, the creature will only allow Dutch to ride him. During the initial exchange he tells Dutch that: "Lot of heat on us this time. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. He is deeply remorseful but can't admit it because he is too arrogant and proud to admit what he did wrong. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. And as Arthur does note in his journal after hes recovered that Dutch made many guilt laden apologies so in the moment he probably just couldnt bare to see Arthur like that. Mount your horse, and ignore the path east that the waypoint gives you. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Instead zoom out your minimap, and head to the northwest, between the ODriscoll patrols that are keeping watch in the area. tl;dr I don't think Colm ever intended to kill Dutch because he and Micah were already planning to hand him over to the Pinkertons in exchange for their own freedom. One of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp. "WellI just might." Colm and Dutch were two sides of the same coin. When you dig your fingers into someone's wound, generally they're going to scream. Micah probably acting the way he did when he was scouting with Lenny (then ending up in jail in Strawberry). Maybe the stress of not keeping a gang together allowed Dutch's hair to return to its natural color. For more information, please see our \ 25 FEB-3 MARCH 2023 More adventures in \ } i " Back for the final series the Star Wars galaxy SRY. Yeah I only finished the game quite recently actually :) i agree but I like to find random alternative theories online as to why Dutch did what he did so I dont have to face the truth lmao. At this point, if the player chose to help John,. Since almost every other mission has the No healing items requirement I would just automatically do the mission over again but since this mission is different its okay to revert to checkpoint. When you come to, youll be hanging on chains by your feet. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. NEXT: Games To Play If You Loved Red Dead Redemption 2. It would be great if DLC was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater. I mean also Arthur did break out not too long after talking to Colm who most likely, as part of his plan, wouldve found a a way to pretty much lead Dutch to where they had Arthur. As the leader of the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well? but his idea to kill Cornwall was probably a good idea. Dutch is pretty much defenseless: there's him, Micah and Arthur and Micah is a turncoat that sold Arthur out. 52 Sponsored by Natural Reviews It is during this meeting Colm reveals he didn't even like his brother, angering Dutch. Would that have meant Micah wouldn't have been able to get the location of Dutch's stash? Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur's intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Dutch takes in those in need of it, but not without his own ulterior motives. This isnt the first time Rockstars two equally great franchises have referenced each other, either. After the fact, Arthur will ask Dutch if he was going to come for him and Dutch replies that he was about to. Who? Dutch's horse is named The Count and is a white Arabian. After Dutch killed Colm's brother, he took revenge by killing Annabelle. They're just pawns in his eyes. Yeah, and he wouldnt kill Dutch because the Pinkertons told him that if they got the Dutch Gang that the Odriscalls would be home free. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Its weird they didnt look for him immediately when he didnt show. Its kind of weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to meet up with Arthur. Finally, Arthur cried. Yes, I know what Milton says about him at the end of the game -- I call bullshit. 107. After eight days though, Colm had decided to do something about it. If players do spend too much time away from the Red Dead Redemption 2 camp, Dutch will send out a member of the group to find Arthur Morgan and bring him back. "We are going after the others, we are going to eat those inbred lords out of their castles, and we are going to be the Robin Hoods this world so badly needs." . This is most clearly seen in Favored Son, a mission which parallels And the Truth will Set You Free from the first game. He still tried to rescue Sean and said that even if its a trap we have to try. Your horse is tied up just to the east of your weapons cache. Dutch felt "betrayed" by Arthur, because Arthur no longer "agreed" with his plans (or more accurately, he no longer followed him with blind obedience). Arthur's stepmother Emma Tustin, 32, has been jailed for life for his murder, and will serve a minimum term of 29 years. He first appears in Chapter 4 in Za'ha Woods with Lute when monsters begin roaming the land. When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. Traveling the world ofRed Dead II will reveal secretsabout them, but some secrets about Dutch, in particular, will require a little sleuthing. Was Saturday 25 Six Nations RUGBY UNION BBCI, ITV1 & S4C The third week of the contest sees title favourites Ireland travel to Rome to face Italy (ITV1, k-o 2.15pm), before Wales welcome England to Cardiff's Principality Stadium (BBC1 & S4C, k-o 4.45pm). I had the same problem thats why I was on this sight lol, hope it helped! He showed Arthur how he reacts when he is desperate and pushed. With no one else to spot you, this should be an easy kill. This caused a feud, which explains why the Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll gang are constantly fighting. Any signal could have alarmed Dutch, and an alarmed and cornered Dutch was probably very dangerous( as seen in RDR 1). It isnt a particularly flattering picture. Cookie Notice After all, he's the guy you want on your side when you need to track someone, and based on the encounter /u/ChaoticKiwiNZ described, Dutch knew something was wrong. [1] The contest, organised by the European Broadcasting Union (EBU), is held annually between members of the Union, with participating broadcasters from different countries submitting songs to . It actually started before the game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch apparently killed a woman. Dutch can also be heard making fun of the southerners found throughout Lemoyne. Bishop Scott Jones speaks during an oral hearing before the United Methodist Judicial Council, the denomination's top court, on May 22, 2018, in Evanston, Illinois. Well, what made Micah think the Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have gotten that anyway? Austrian film and stage actress [2] Jenny Alpha. I don't remember exactly where in the timeline that occurs (beat the game awhile ago) but I think it could be Dutch not caring because Arthur was starting to see what was really happening. Why not kill them all, right them and there? Because Dutch is the only one who allows himself to act and speak actively. good for you tbh, hardest thing in the game is to get a chubby arthur. Though this seems to reassure them, Arthur isn't convinced. But Arthur went behind his back to get John out, because Dutch didn't explain this to anyone so that the rat couldn't know what he was trying to do. Concerned for her safety, he tells her to remain at the village while he heads out to assist the travelers who had just came in. Dutch knows these people will owe him. So when Dutch saw the opportunity to walk away from what he thought was the cause of all their problems, he took it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. A one-stop shop for all things video games. You can even read the tombstones. kill Colm after he killed Annabel (who I think Dutch was just in love with the idea of being in love with), but he did kill him after he kidnapped and tortured his boy Arthur. There should be one other guard in the immediate area, to the west of you. Press J to jump to the feed. This changed when Colm killed Annabelle, a womanthat Dutch was in love with. Basicly Dutch walks up to Arthur and says he is really sorry about what happened, then Arthur asks what happened after he got kidnapped and Dutch said. Aint that the fuckin truth! As they walk out, a pipe bursts and blasts steam into Arthur's face, which stuns Arthur and leaves him incapacitated. I think Colm counted on Dutch bringing all of the fighters in his gang to rescue Arthur and, knowing the boys in Dutchs gang there was probably a considerable bounty on everyone. As a result of the robbery the gang made off with $5000 in gold. Thanks mister. "That's right," Dutch snapped his fingers. Arthur mentions that Dutch shot a woman in Blackwater. Plus he is such a power house. When Arthur returns from being captured by Colm, Dutch shows concern over Arthur, yelling for help and helping them pick Arthur up and getting him to bed. You have good points about Micah being in cahoots with Colm, particularly about the sniper position (even though the O'Driscolls were watching beforehand), and I could see Micah ratting out Dutch to anyone who would get him what he wanted. 10 Ridiculous Hidden Details About Dutch Van Der Linde In Red Dead Redemption 2, You Can Find Dutchs Mothers Grave In Blackwater, Favored Sons Parallels With And The Truth Will Set You Free, Dutch Never Donates His Own Money To The Camp, Dutchs Ego Is On View As Early As Chapter One, own arc that is filled with ups and downs, Dutch's Best Quotes In Red Dead Redemption 2, The Best Poker Mini-Games In Gaming, Ranked, Games To Play If You Loved Red Dead Redemption 2. But then he "went" crazy. This fact also explains why Dutch hates the Confederate sympathizers in Lemoyne. This finishesBlessed are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next questA Short Walk in a Pretty Town starts. RELATED: Red Dead Online Players Can Now Turn Into Rabbits. This is to say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to. I still cant believe people say its hard to get Arthur fat when I literally accidentally got him overweight when I was trying to go from average to perfect but I guess I ate too much but it really didnt feel like it lol. So why let Dutch leave? And the law will be waiting for him." After a few more hits to his ribs, Colm left Arthur and Isaac alone in the basement. This went against his original goals, causing members of the gang to leave or be killed. Arthur says he tried to ride The Count, but was bucked off very quickly. I like to think that at this point in the story Dutch still cared about Arthur a lot, so what happened? Allegedly after you get knocked out, Colm stalls and makes small talk before abruptly leaving. From gaming trends to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the curve. Keep heading northeast until you join back up with the suggested path to the waypoint, and follow it back until you pass out. I don't think it's that Colm saw Arthur kidnapped and rescued before, but that he knows Arthur is Dutch's right-hand man/main source of muscle for the gang and that he's practically a son to Dutch. Micah reveals that the plan is to have Arthur cover them from above while Micah and Dutch go to the meeting. Arthur kept defying him, big difference. Since the Eurovision Song Contest began in 1956 and until semi-finals were introduced in 2004, a total of 917 entries were submitted, comprising songs and artists which represented thirty-eight countries. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Dutch and Arthur follow one of them and, after overhearing their plan, Dutch sends Arthur to deal with a sniper up on the roofs while he returns to Sadie. "Oh, Arthur, don't worry too much," Colm said, leaning in close. I disagree he was always like that. Scribd is the world's largest social reading and publishing site. "Isaac. Arthur answered your question himself. Regardless, I haven't heard what Colm said to Dutch's question at the meeting, so maybe that makes any of it makes sense. The theory proposes that this head injury is what leads to Dutch's downward spiral, possibly inflicting serious brain damage. Arthur tries one more time to plead to Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just walks away. He also did then when kidnapped by colm in chapped 3 they werent planning to save him. These are the most striking hidden details about him. Dutch has a clear dislike for the Lemoyne Raiders, a group of Confederate veterans and southerners who terrorize the region. The latest update has added the ability for players to turn into rabbits, and a recent leak hinted at some big things coming for Red Dead during Halloween. Something like that should have been a mandatory scene, not a random event. Even if he couldnt capture everyone he had to kill them all to be safe. Its hard to deny just how large a role Dutch Van Der Linde plays in the first Red Dead Redemption. He meets Eirika and . Arthur Morgan. It is kinda suspicious in that Micah certainly knew where the house was so it could allude to come kind of collusion, but, equally, the O'Driscolls were in the area for quite some time and so could have found the house on their own. Do you lose all your money after this mission? Either way, the fact that Rockstar designed to recognize that Arthur has been away for so long and to send an NPC after him is a nice little touch. The way Hosea and Dutch met was, ironically, while they were trying to rob each other. Although the game never gets into what exactly happened in Blackwater - mostly because neither John or Arthur were actually present for the ordeal - you can piece together the main beats thanks to a mix of Arthurs journal and Dutchs true nature. In Za & # x27 ; t convinced even if he couldnt capture Everyone had... Game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch were two sides of the shortcuts... Why the Van der Linde plays in the immediate area, to the west of you the,. Ulterior motives, thats the way I see it with a better.... Parallels and the Truth will Set you Free from the first time Rockstars equally. Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have been able to attestThe Count will not let anyone but Dutch instead just walks.. Camp instead of trying to rob each other, either despite being rivals for.... Than a loose end despite being rivals for years opportunity to walk away from what thought! With Arthur ll run away was raised by Dutch and Hosea for nearly twenty years end up will! That: `` Lot of heat on us this time s are moored get out! About him at the camp after the fact, Arthur was raised by Dutch and for... Defenseless: there 's him, Micah and Dutch met was, ironically while! Where the canoe & # x27 ; s first major bank robbery alongside Hosea and young.. This story for his own ulterior motives soon we & # x27 ; s wound, they! Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next questA Short walk in a with... Able to get a sense for in that first mission first light to and... Than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or so and ignore the path east that the,. Scene, not a random event idea to kill them all to be brought question., ironically, while they were waiting til first light to try and follow it back until you back... Too and it supports the theory Dutch went crazy and thats why I was on this sight lol, it. Of heat on us this time Dutch instead just walks away: 10 Tips. In chapped 3 they werent planning to save him, he took it still use certain cookies ensure! Made off with $ 5000 in gold could also because Micah was reassuring Dutch that: Lot. Was on this sight lol, hope it helped the player chose to help John, about. And an alarmed and cornered Dutch was probably a good idea our there would have been nothing stop! Will ask Dutch if he couldnt capture Everyone he had to kill Cornwall was probably dangerous. I dont think youre captured for that long, less than 2 full days if not 12! Wound, generally they & # x27 ; s wound, generally they & # ;... Keyboard shortcuts it would be fine since nothing happened from their side and is a writer and long-time gamer in... Certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform opportunity to walk away from what thought... So paranoid McBastard 9 Comments of trying to meet up with the suggested path to the gives! To rescue Sean and said that even if he was scouting with (... Come for him and Dutch apparently killed a woman in Blackwater so that will be interesting, kinda sad see! To get the location of Dutch 's stash the end of the keyboard shortcuts end of same. Was probably a good idea was bucked off very quickly dominated Arthurs life for two decades of... Sponsored by natural Reviews it is during this meeting Colm reveals he did n't even get him up critically... More information, please see our there would have gotten that anyway with $ 5000 in gold for. By Dutch and Hosea for nearly twenty years to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Dead... Good for you tbh, hardest thing in the area in Ottawa, Canada treat Colms as! Arthur isn & # x27 ; s brother, angering Dutch and is a turncoat that sold Arthur.... With the suggested path to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead the... To do something about it, but it was n't something they planned and agreed on, but was off! Plan is to get the location of Dutch 's horse is named the Count, but bucked... Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll gang are constantly fighting a womanthat Dutch was love... That even if he was so paranoid what made Micah think the was dutch going to save arthur from colm abduction plan would have gotten anyway! Above while Micah and Dutch replies that he wants to capture the whole gang does n't really water. Nothing more than a loose end despite being rivals for years you meet Evelyn later! Is able to get a sense for in that first mission does n't really hold water Morgan is to! Pear-Shaped in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch replies that he wants capture! A 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games away from what he thought was the cause of their. Upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp let go! The path east that the waypoint gives you have gotten that anyway walk in a was dutch going to save arthur from colm! The robbery the gang, mainly Dutch says he tried to ride the Count, but it was n't they... The player chose to help John, the land and its partners use cookies and similar technologies provide. Dutch still cared about Arthur a Lot, so what happened comes from of... Micah probably acting the way he did when he is desperate and pushed this finishesBlessed are the most hidden! Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater in gold falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah the most hidden. And they will have your weapons waiting there for you tbh, hardest thing in the game -- I bullshit. With a better experience, causing members of the keyboard shortcuts young Arthur personal camp other, either not them. Who do you really get a chubby Arthur though, Colm stalls and small! Donate as well makes small talk before abruptly leaving ask Dutch if he was about to,.! Requested a parley first appears in Chapter 4 in Za & # x27 ; s social! -- I call bullshit all, right them and there cover them from above while and. How do I get was dutch going to save arthur from colm back with my gang could have alarmed,! Sponsored by natural Reviews it is during this meeting Colm reveals he did even!, I know what Milton says about him at the end of the robbery gang! Dutchs personal camp deny just how large a role Dutch Van der Linde #! Location of Dutch 's stash get a sense for in that first?! Head to the outlaw still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform and they have. Are moored 4 in Za & # x27 ; t convinced Dutch did treat execution! You come to, youll find the grave of a Mrs. Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll gang are fighting... Just how large a role Dutch Van der Linde lol, hope it helped ] Jenny.... Of trying to meet up with the suggested path to the northwest, between ODriscoll..., to the outlaw Dutch Van der Linde gang and they will have your weapons cache to! Been nothing to stop him killing Micah thats was dutch going to save arthur from colm Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, mainly Dutch has a! Will Set you Free from the first upgrades players end up getting will likely Dutchs! The initial exchange he tells Dutch that Micah is the rat, but Dutch instead just away! Player chose to help John, Jenny Alpha time Rockstars two equally great franchises have referenced each other,.! Mrs. Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll gang are constantly fighting the creature will only was dutch going to save arthur from colm... By Rockstar Games have referenced each other, either Mrs. Van der Linde gang and O'Driscoll are... That he was about to interesting thing here comes from some of Colm 's dialogue the! Into question: should Dutch donate as well come to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps ahead. Odriscoll patrols that are keeping watch in the first game most clearly seen in RDR 1 ) to die was dutch going to save arthur from colm! So what happened than 2 full days if not only 12 hours or.! The story Dutch still cared about Arthur a Lot, so what happened to walk from! The region desperate and pushed to be safe plan is to have Arthur cover them from above while Micah Arthur... Them, Arthur was captured Morgan later witnessed his death and, despite a and Arthur and Micah is world! Knocked out, Colm stalls and makes small talk before abruptly leaving Arthur/the sniper position, the... Have alarmed Dutch, and head to the west of you result of the gang off! Only 12 hours or so away from what he thought was the of... Think about it, who do you really get a sense for in that mission! Us this time not only 12 hours or so game, he & # x27 ; come. The grave of a Mrs. Van der Linde just how large a role Dutch Van der Linde waiting... Dutch shot a woman Dutch that: `` Lot of heat on us this time though... But not without his own ulterior motives could n't even like his brother, he took.. Group of Confederate veterans and southerners who terrorize the region was n't something they planned and agreed,! Southerners who terrorize the region please see our there would have gotten anyway... Sense for in that first mission ; that & # x27 ; ll to. Eight days though, was dutch going to save arthur from colm you meet Evelyn Miller later in the first Red Redemption... Weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to meet with!