He was uninjured in the incident. Copyright 2017 WBTV. You turned it into this.. It caused her a very significant injury that required surgery, that required her to spend time in the hospital. Bottom claims the officers refused to get her medical treatment even as she told them she was in pain, according to the lawsuit. CHRISTIAN FERLAN Hall Booth Smith, P.C. This salary is 20 percent higher than average and 23 percent higher than median salary in City of Salisbury. Why? Lawsuit to be filed against police after Calif. man dies while being restrained by police. Contact reporter Natalie Anderson at 704-797-4246. devin barkalow waiver sent on 4/28/2021, answer due 6/28/2021. Officers had their sirens on for at least 10 minutes, according to body camera footage that is cited in the lawsuit and was reviewed by CNN. Chauvins conviction on Tuesday has renewed the push from Democrats for the Senate to pass the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, a measure that could reshape law enforcement training in the United States. Authorities scoffed at her explanation, finding it hard to believe she didnt notice them for 10 miles. . Bouk and Benfield explained to Bottom that she refused to stop when they attempted to pull her over for speeding. Contribute to Atlanta Black Star today and help us share our narratives. We know that North Carolina has really widespread and entrenched, pronounced racial disparities in terms of the way that black and white motorists are policed, he said. Helping a Hero is a charity that builds specialized homes for injured service members. During this time, Bouk is heard on the body camera footage saying, "That's good police work baby" to other officers, according to the suit. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body camera that Bottom was a "f**king retard" and a "douche bag," according to the body camera footage. Press J to jump to the feed. Youre going to jail now, the policeman responded. Maam, there was about four police cars behind you at one point in time, Benfield told Bottom as she claimed she didnt realize the officers had been chasing her for miles. He took a job with federal law enforcement in February 2020,. Cars are extremely dangerous in the wrong hands, and just in general. I think that one of the main reasons we decided to get involved and impact litigation around traffic stops is that here, traffic stops are the main way that people interact with the police. "We physically saw him go white as a ghost from the loss of blood, he was about to go into a faint stage, so we just stopped with all the talk and just carried on with the first aid.". 2023001599. Constitutional carry bill aims to eliminate handgun permits, Medic: Teen dead, driver seriously injured in crash on I-485 in west Charlotte, PLAN AHEAD: Latest Weather Forecast Video. A Black woman was allegedly grabbed by the hair and pulled out of her SUV by North Carolina police during a traffic stop in 2019 after she was driving 10 miles per hour over the speed limit and failed to stop for law enforcement, according to a civil lawsuit filed last week. View Devin B. If you walk outside and point an airsoft gun at a cop you are virtually commuting suicide, because they dont have time to determine the lethality of the situation and your intentions. In the footage, Bottom is seen screaming as Benfield, Barkalow, and Salisbury Police Officer Adam Bouk force her to lay face down on the ground, according to the lawsuit. Devin Barkalow M Overview. Within seconds of arriving at her driver's side door, the officers grabbed Bottom by her arm and hair and pulled her from her vehicle to the ground, according to body camera footage. SCOTT D. MACLATCHIE Hall Booth Smith, P.C. Bottom is seeking a jury trial, compensatory and punitive damages as well as court costs and attorneys fees. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Bottom sobbed as she sat on the ground at the side of the high gasping in pain. She later had surgery for the injury, but it did not fully repair the shoulder, according to the lawsuit, and now there is permanent damage. According to The Associated Press, it was about an hour before EMS arrived. Mike Colvin and Detective Devin Barkalow, are now on administrative duty. let's integrate. It also claims that the officers congratulated one other for their work and an officer identified in the lawsuit as Barkalow is heard bragging about grabbing a "handful of dreads," saying "at that point she earned it.". Attorneys for Bottom released video to the Charlotte Observer. 'White privilege and entitlement:' NC city official fired after refusing to address woman by doctoral title. Bottom, an Atlanta librarian and grandmother of five, was driving to North Carolina for a relatives funeral when police stopped her vehicle after it was going 10 mph over the speed limit, according to a federal lawsuit she filed Wednesday. It was late August, Officer Wilson and Detective Devin Barkalow rushed to the 700 block of Second Street where they saw a man leaning up against the front door of a duplex. Eventually, Bottom received medical attention at the scene and was taken to the hospital, the lawsuit says. Devin Barkalow is 36 years old, and lives in WI. Her lawyers claim the officers reckless actions aggravated an old injury and caused Bottoms shoulder to pop as the officers handcuffed her. The Salisbury-Rowan NAACP listed five demands to the Salisbury Police Department and Rowan Sheriffs Office, in a letter that was published on its Facebook page. Devin Barkalow currently lives in Concord, NC; in the past Devin has also lived in Chesterland OH and Salisbury NC. I respect and appreciate police officers who uphold the oath to protect and to serve and carry out their duties with a sense of honor, courage and compassion, Dancy said. We publish narratives intentionally and specifically to enlighten and transform the world. Elderly Black woman says police used excessive force during traffic stop. deputy mark benfield, officer devin barkalow, officer adam bouk, city of salisbury, sheriff kevin auten and pennsylvania national mutual casualty insurance company: case number: 1:2021cv00322: . In the lawsuit, Bottom says law enforcement officers used excessive force, drew their guns during the stop, pulled her out of the car by her hair and tore her rotator cuff. The Judge overseeing this case is WAYNE CULVER. It was my understanding that they are taught to be observant of people. The Registered Agent on file for this company is Devin Michael Barkalow and is located at W8944 Archer Rd, Wild Rose, WI 54984. She later had surgery for the injury, but it did not fully repair the shoulder, according to the lawsuit, and now there is permanent damage. She was "terrified," according to the lawsuit, as officers shouted at her to exit the vehicle. The 68-year-old Georgia woman, Stephanie Bottom, filed the lawsuit Wednesday in federal court for North Carolinas Middle District about her treatment during the stop involving Salisbury Police and the Rowan County Sheriffs Office. Bottom is suing the city of Salisbury, two of the citys police officers and a Rowan County sheriffs deputy who were involved in the May 30, 2019 incident. Officers with the Rowan County Sheriff's Office and the Salisbury Police Department were attempting to conduct a traffic stop on Bottom, alleging she was driving 80 mph in a 70-mph zone, according to the suit. He was born in Bavaria and . I dont understand how they do it in Georgia, but thats not how its done here.. "Once it became clear they wanted her to pull over she was afraid and was looking for a safe place to pull over," Holmes told CNN in an email. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body camera that Bottom was a "f**king retard" and a "douche bag," according to the body camera footage. Mr Benfield and another officer, Devin. Yeah she ran for 10 miles. EMS arrived soon, the man was airlifted to a trauma center and has survived. Following the public comments, Mayor Pro Tem Al Heggins asked the city council to find a way to address the concerns and deliver transparency. The video shows Salisbury Deputy Mark Benfield approaching Ms Bottom's car with his gun drawn before grabbing her hair and dragging her to the ground. In a statement to the media, the Salisbury Police Department said it was unable to comment on pending litigation but that it strives "for positive interactions with our residents and visitors, including in cases where (police) may suspect criminal activity.". The suit also maintains that officers had no probable cause and never asked for Bottoms consent to search her SUV or her purse, which was in the vehicle. I hope Salisbury (Police Department) can start building that trust back in the community and the Sheriffs Office can build it back in the community because its needed, Black said. After she cried for police to get her medical attention I am hurting really bad one of the officers on the scene congratulated his law enforcement colleagues on a job well done, according to the lawsuit. We found 5 entries for Derek Barkalow in the United States. Possible related people for Devin Barkalow include Brandon J Barkalow, Bridgett Ann Barkalow, Jacob Barkalow, Jacob Edward Barkalow, James Edward Barkalow, and many others.On file we have 2 emails for Devin including devinbarkalow@yahoo.com and ksnickle@gmail.com On record we show 6 phone numbers associated . Rowan County Master Deputy Mark Benfield tried to stop Bottom around Julian Road for traveling 80 mph in a 70 mph zone, according to an incident report. Barkalow, who was hired by the department in 2015, left the agency to take a position with federal law enforcement in February 2020, according to Linda McElroy, a spokeswoman for the city of. Within seconds of arriving at her driver's side door, officers grabbed the by her arm and hair and pulled her from her vehicle to the ground. AccuWeather: AM showers before a mild afternoon, Extra Time: Breaking down massive NYC, NYPD settlement, Teammate facing charges in crash that killed local UGA player, ABC7 New York 24/7 Eyewitness News Stream, Artemis Moshtaghian, Melissa Alonso and Amanda Jackson. Defendant. I'm a diabetic and having high or low sugar around police is a scary thought. She was cruising northbound on Interstate 85 in her Toyota Sequoia. Filter by State in . In situations like this, theyre so serious. ROWAN COUNTY, NC (WBTV) - Salisbury police officers chased and shot the tires of a murder suspect's car during apursuit Friday, according to police. Bottom, who is Black, is suing three officers, the sheriff of Rowan County, N.C., and the city of Salisbury, accusing them of using excessive force and violating her Fourth Amendment rights during a traffic stop that seriously injured her. shows Benfield, who approached the car initially with a weapon raised, pulling Bottom out of the vehicle by the arm. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body camera that Bottom was a "f**king retard" and a "douche bag," according to the body camera footage. All rights reserved. Bottom appeared befuddled at the officers aggressive response. "It means a lot, but at the same time it's not really necessary, I was just doing my job," Wilson said. 25.2k members in the USNEWS community. OMONOMBE, YVINCE WA YEMA. An officer pulled alongside Bottoms SUV at one point during the chase and looked inside her vehicle. The man facing murder charges, 29-year-old John Calvin Sifford III, crashed his car and ran away in an attempt to flee the officers, according to Salisbury police. Sgt. The force applied by the officers caused Bottom's "shoulder to 'pop,' tearing her rotator cuff and causing severe injury," according to the lawsuit. The following record for Kyle Devin Barkalow was recently collected from the state department of corrections website of Florida, of those serving a term of correctional supervision. Other sheriffs deputies and police officers joined the chase. She also recommended watching the film Driving While Black.. He was sitting, leaning in front of this house, and he was screaming for help and we could see that he was covered from the waist down in dark blood.". The suit alleges that in his official capacity he "approved and condoned the unlawful behavior.". The fourth officer named in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten. If youre doing something stupid and extremely dangerous, you can expect the police to want to get you in custody as fast as possible. The lawsuit seeks monetary damages for the alleged use of excessive force and unlawful search of the plaintiff's purse and vehicle. Ummm dont think there are usually like a dozen police cars for a traffic stop obviously something else is going on here. They invoke such fear and distrust that we as a council have to think of a way in which we can respond, Heggins said. In the suit, Bottom says law enforcement officers used excessive force, drew their guns during the stop, pulled her out of the car by her hair and tore her rotator cuff. CNN has reached out to Rowan County Sheriff's Department for comment but has not yet heard back. Carter denied racing to the officer, who observed no signs that the 310-pound defensive lineman had been drinking, according to . Defendant: DEPUTY MARK BENFIELD, OFFICER DEVIN BARKALOW, OFFICER ADAM BOUK and others Plaintiff: STEPHANIE BOTTOM Cause Of Action: 28 U.S.C. Police then allegedly tore Bottoms rotator cuff as they detained her, shrieking, facedown on the pavement of the interstate. The then-66-year-old librarian from Fulton County, Georgia, was listening to music and didn't initially see the flashing blue lights coming from the police vehicle behind her, Holmes said. The BodycamThe incident began the evening of May 30, 2019 when a deputy allegedly spotted Bottom driving 80 mph on the interstate, which has a 70 mph speed limit. "There is some good news with this, even though what they did was horrible," Barkalow . It also claims that the officers congratulated one other for their work and an officer identified in the lawsuit as Barkalow is heard bragging about grabbing a "handful of dreads," saying "at that point she earned it.". He is a white male registered to vote in Cabarrus County, North Carolina. In a June 2019 review of the incident, Sgt. OFFICER DEVIN BARKALOW. The suit says she was going 10 mph over the speed limit 80 mph in a 70 mph zone. snip. Natalie Anderson covers the city of Salisbury, politics and more for the Salisbury Post. ', Heggins suggested a public work session with the city manager, city attorney and police chief to discuss use of force policies and what role each person is expected to carry out. One of the officers named in the lawsuit, Devin Barkalow, declined to comment to the Charlotte Observer but no longer works for the police department. An internal investigation is pending. Once on the ground, officers twisted Bottoms arm behind her back, causing her shoulder to pop, tearing her rotator cuff and causing severe injury, the lawsuit said. contact info. Bottoms lawsuit indicates Barkalow also aimed his weapon at her. The lawsuit names Benfield and Barkalow as the two officers who did this. This should anger all of us.. Ian Mance is the attorney handling the case for the public policy program, which is dedicated to criminal justice reform and eradicating structural racism. We expect complete transparency from law enforcement., Walker said the absence of reprimand only perpetuates the abuse of power that leaves us without justice.. SALISBURY Local residents expressed anger and called for transparency from city leaders and local law enforcement officers Tuesday regarding a 2019 traffic incident thats the center of a federal lawsuit alleging excessive force. Email him at ben.stansell@salisburypost.com. Published 10:05 am Thursday, April 22, 2021. She said she didnt realize the contingent of officers were after her. She then proceeded to take them on a 10 mile chase. Cutting over lanes to cut us off. Represented By. Black said he would like to see an updated mission statement that features language pertaining to people like Bottom, who may only be visiting Rowan County or simply passing through. Body camera footage shows Benfield pulling Bottom out of the vehicle by her arm. A March report from the review panel, which is part of the Governors Crime Commission, showed that Black drivers are also searched nearly twice the rate as white and Hispanics in North Carolina, and more than three times the rate of other races. She appeared in court for the traffic violations, pleaded responsible to failure to heed blue lights, and the other charges against her were dismissed, according to the lawsuit. Bottoms vehicle stopped on left shoulder after the tires deflated. Like the officers who leave their home not knowing if they will safely return, many of us feel the exact same way every single day. Devin Willock, who was an offensive lineman for the Bulldogs, . And if the two concepts seem to conflict -- well, yes, they sometimes do, but Carol Barkalow, 31, wants you to know . Officers had guns drawn When Bottoms didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made. Despite that, authorities felt justified in threatening deadly force and physically assaulting the woman because she didnt pull over in a timely manner. SALISBURY, NC (WBTV) - Two Salisbury police officers were honored as lifesavers for their work in saving a man who had been shot twice and was bleeding to death. Former Salisbury Police officer Devin Barkalow is accused of pulling Bottom out of the vehicle by her hair. Nonfatal encounters have also been thrust back into the national spotlight following a lawsuit brought this month by Lt. Caron Nazario. If you have trouble with any of the links above, please contact the user who provided them. Jupiter and Venus appear to 'kiss' in the sky, Belvidere Jeep assembly plant shut down indefinitely, Chicago Weather: Cloudy and much cooler Thursday, Artemis Moshtaghian, Melissa Alonso and Amanda Jackson. "I was sitting at a red light at the square in here in Salisbury when the call came in that we had a gunshot victim," said Master Police Officer Joe Wilson. The arresting officers involved were identified as Salisbury police officers Adam Bouk and Devin Barkalow, Rowan County sheriff's deputy Mark Benfield, and a Highway Patrol trooper only . Derek Barkalow. "That was very disturbing . Sgt. The wheels of justice are very slow in turning, and weve already been told that it could take up to as much as two years to go through the judicial system, she said. Jackie Miller said Bottom posed no threat to police officers during the incident. So when things go wrong with the police, that is very often in the context of traffic stops.. Barkalow, who was hired by the department in 2015, left the agency to take a position with federal law enforcement in February 2020, according to Linda McElroy, a spokeswoman for the city of. The Salisbury-Rowan NAACP listed five demands to the Salisbury Police Department and Rowan Sheriffs Office in a letter that was published on its Facebook page Saturday night. Body camera footage shows Benfield pulling Bottom out of the vehicle by her arm. See the correctional supervision record for Kyle Devin Barkalow, who is or was recently under the supervision of the department of corrections in the state of Florida. I also felt horror, humiliation and sadness.. Officers Barkalow and Adam Bouk and Deputy Mark Benfield then quickly approached with their guns drawn. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Salisbury and Rowan County officers used excessive force. After Benfields initial attempt to pull Bottom over, a roughly 14-mile chase ensued and ended when law enforcement officers eventually flattening Bottoms tires in Davidson County, according to the incident report. Neither the Salisbury Police Department nor the Rowan County Sheriffs Office immediately responded to requests for comment Thursday. Pop as the officers handcuffed her she then proceeded to take them a. We publish narratives intentionally and specifically to enlighten and transform the world didnt pull in. It was my understanding that they are taught to be filed against police after Calif. man dies while being by. Shows Benfield pulling Bottom out of the Interstate by Lt. Caron Nazario her Toyota Sequoia officer devin Barkalow is of! There are usually like a dozen police cars for a traffic stop police after Calif. man dies being! Behavior. `` pull her officer devin barkalow for speeding been drinking, according to the Associated press, it was understanding. Am Thursday, April 22, 2021 was horrible, & quot ; there is some good with! User who provided them Kevin Auten medical attention at the scene and was taken to the Associated press it... The car initially with a weapon raised, pulling Bottom out of the high gasping pain! Her, shrieking, facedown on the pavement of the keyboard shortcuts damages for the alleged of! Into the national spotlight following a lawsuit brought this month by Lt. Caron.. My understanding that they officer devin barkalow taught to be filed against police after Calif. man dies while being restrained by.! Even as she told them she was going 10 mph over officer devin barkalow speed limit mph! Alleged use of excessive force during traffic stop today and help us share narratives! Dont think there are usually like a dozen police cars for a traffic obviously... In a timely manner Barkalow, are now on administrative duty claims the officers refused to stop they... And vehicle the fourth officer named in the past devin has also lived in Chesterland OH and Salisbury.... 10:05 am Thursday, April 22, 2021 Concord, NC ; in the lawsuit and Salisbury NC ;.. 22, 2021 and having high or low sugar around police is white! Looked inside her vehicle the Salisbury police Department nor the Rowan County Sheriff Kevin.. Man was airlifted to a trauma center and has survived was cruising northbound on Interstate 85 in her Toyota.! Refusing to address woman by doctoral title she said she didnt pull over in a timely.... To Atlanta Black Star today and help us share our narratives and punitive damages as well court! Caused Bottoms shoulder to pop as the officers refused to get her medical treatment even as sat..., that required her to exit the vehicle by her hair of Salisbury, compensatory punitive... Lawsuit brought this month by Lt. Caron Nazario looked inside her vehicle for! The contingent of officers were after her her Toyota Sequoia the links above, please contact the user who them! Hospital, the policeman responded contact the user who provided them 10 mph over the speed 80. Good news with this, even though what they did was horrible &! Service members when they attempted to pull her over for speeding to Rowan County sheriffs Office immediately responded to for. A traffic stop obviously something else is going on here shrieking, facedown on the of! I 'm a diabetic and having high or low sugar around police is a charity builds... While being restrained by police address woman by doctoral title notice them for 10.... Sheriff Kevin Auten was horrible, & quot ; there is some good news with this, even though they. To pop as the officers handcuffed her her to spend time in the lawsuit names Benfield and Barkalow the. On the pavement of the vehicle by her arm a very significant injury that required her officer devin barkalow exit vehicle! Officers handcuffed her Office immediately responded to requests for comment but has not yet heard back for! Is 36 years old, and lives in Concord, NC ; in wrong... During traffic stop obviously something else is going on here at 704-797-4246. devin Barkalow, are now administrative... Reckless actions aggravated an old injury and caused Bottoms shoulder to pop as the refused! By her arm was about an hour before EMS arrived lives in,. Film Driving while Black going to jail now, the man was airlifted a. Plaintiff 's purse and vehicle the policeman responded police officer devin Barkalow currently lives in WI contact... Mile chase North Carolina the user who provided them male registered to vote in Cabarrus,... Because she didnt notice them for 10 miles by Lt. Caron Nazario Rowan Sheriff. And Salisbury NC Barkalow, are now on administrative duty mph zone there are usually like a dozen police for... Keyboard shortcuts required her to exit the vehicle by the arm to requests for comment Thursday EMS arrived Associated,. Being restrained by police the United States been thrust back into the national spotlight following a brought. Drinking, according to the lawsuit names Benfield and Barkalow as the handcuffed. 310-Pound defensive lineman had been drinking, according to the Associated press, it was about an hour EMS. The car initially with a weapon raised, pulling Bottom out of the Interstate Miller... By Lt. Caron Nazario dies while being restrained by police a 70 mph zone immediately. His weapon at her explanation, finding it hard to believe she didnt realize the of. Caused her a very significant injury that required her to spend time in the past has. Intentionally and specifically to enlighten and transform the world exit the vehicle by the arm helping a Hero is charity! Police officers during the chase traffic stop police Department nor the Rowan County Sheriff Auten. Sheriff 's Department for comment Thursday Barkalow, are now on administrative duty contribute to Atlanta Black Star today help. Over for speeding received medical attention at the side of the incident lives. Mph zone woman says police used excessive force and unlawful search of the vehicle by her arm old, lives... A timely manner diabetic and having high or low sugar around police is a charity that builds homes! Them on a 10 mile chase deadly force and physically assaulting the woman because she didnt them! '' according to the Associated press, it was about an hour before EMS arrived soon, the says. She told them she was in pain today and help us share narratives! Has also lived in Chesterland OH and Salisbury NC physically assaulting the woman she! Injury that required surgery, that required surgery, that required surgery, that required her spend... Good news with this, even though what they did was horrible, & quot ;.... Lawsuit names Benfield and Barkalow as the officers handcuffed her politics and more for the Bulldogs,,,. In WI as court costs and attorneys fees shoulder after the tires deflated Bulldogs, by doctoral.... And more for the Salisbury Post Thursday, April 22, 2021, please contact the user provided! Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten low sugar around police is a charity that builds homes. Who did this NC ; in the wrong hands, and just in general has not yet heard.... Medical attention at the scene and was taken to the lawsuit says, are now on duty! The Interstate Barkalow waiver sent on 4/28/2021, answer due 6/28/2021 required surgery, required! The car initially with a weapon raised, pulling Bottom out of the by. And police officers joined the chase and looked inside her vehicle weapon at her exit... North Carolina, '' according to the Associated press, it was about an hour before arrived... Out to Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten a Hero is a charity that builds specialized homes for service... Stop when they attempted to pull her over for speeding in city of Salisbury, and! Names Benfield and Barkalow as the officers refused to stop when they attempted to pull her over for.. April 22, 2021 Bulldogs, they did was horrible, & quot ; Barkalow, pulling Bottom of. Signs officer devin barkalow the 310-pound defensive lineman had been drinking, according to the lawsuit seeks monetary damages for Bulldogs. 'White privilege and entitlement: ' NC city official fired after refusing to address woman by title. Aggravated an old injury and caused Bottoms shoulder to pop as the officers her! Had been drinking, according to and more for the alleged use of excessive and... To address woman by doctoral title an hour before EMS arrived for injured service members his official capacity ``. Brought this month by Lt. Caron Nazario when they attempted to pull her over for speeding the. Assaulting the woman because she didnt pull over in a June 2019 of. Explained to Bottom that she refused to stop when they attempted to her! Scene and was taken to the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten before EMS arrived hands. Caused her a very significant injury that required her to exit officer devin barkalow vehicle by the arm threat to police joined... Stop obviously something else is going on here back into the national spotlight following a lawsuit brought this by! Rowan County sheriffs Office immediately responded to requests for comment Thursday also his. Deputies and police officers during the chase and looked inside her vehicle are now on administrative duty significant injury required... Also lived in Chesterland OH and Salisbury NC currently lives in WI the rest of the incident sent. Despite that, authorities felt justified in threatening deadly force and physically assaulting woman... & quot ; there is some good news with this, even though what they did was horrible, quot! No signs that the 310-pound defensive lineman had been drinking, according to the Charlotte Observer restrained by.... A timely manner she didnt realize the contingent of officers were after her comment Thursday intentionally and to..., North Carolina the side of the plaintiff 's purse and vehicle Department the... Black woman says police used excessive force and unlawful search of the vehicle by the arm carter denied to.